Опубликовать статью Вход и регистрация
Расширенный поиск
Разделы статьи

ПОЛИТИКА ЯКУТСКОЙ АССР В СФЕРЕ НАУЧНОГО ИЗУЧЕНИЯ АРКТИКИ В 1945-1991 ГГ. (ОБЗОР ЛИТЕРАТУРЫ)

Научная статья
Егоров П.М.
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.23670/IRJ.2022.116.2.106
Выпуск: № 2 (116), 2022
Опубликована:
2022/02/17
PDF

ПОЛИТИКА ЯКУТСКОЙ АССР В СФЕРЕ НАУЧНОГО ИЗУЧЕНИЯ АРКТИКИ В 1945-1991 ГГ. (ОБЗОР ЛИТЕРАТУРЫ)

Обзорная статья

Егоров П.М.*

ORCID: 0000-0002-1107-2662,

Институт гуманитарных исследований и проблем малочисленных народов Севера Сибирского отделения РАН, Якутск, Россия

* Корреспондирующий автор (epm77[at]mail.ru)

Аннотация

В статье приводится анализ обзора литературы российских и якутских авторов, посвященной политике Советского государства в области научного изучения Якутской Арктики в 1945-1991. В этот период наука активно развивалась и способствовала решению внутри- и внешнеполитических задач, был накоплен мощный исследовательский задел, что позволяет современной России и сегодня быть безусловным лидером в некоторых областях освоения Арктики. Однако, среди отечественной и зарубежной научной литературы до настоящего времени отсутствуют специальные работы, посвященные деятельности региональных органов государственной власти в организации научных исследований Якутской Арктики. Отдельные аспекты темы, главным образом, касающиеся научного, промышленного и транспортного освоения Якутской части Арктики освещены в обобщающих трудах, посвященных истории освоения  Российской Арктики.

Ключевые слова: научная политика, Якутская АССР, научные исследования, Арктика, Якутия.

POLICY OF THE YAKUT ASSR IN THE SCIENTIFIC STUDY OF THE ARCTIC IN THE PERIOD FROM 1945 TO 1991 (A LITERATURE REVIEW)

Review article

Yegorov P.M.*

ORCID: 0000-0002-1107-2662,

Institute for Humanities Research and Indigenous Studies of the North, Russian Academy of Sciences, Siberian Branch, Yakutsk, Russia

* Corresponding author (epm77[at]mail.ru)

Abstract

The article provides an analysis of the review of the literature of Russian and Yakut authors dedicated to the policy of the Soviet state in the field of scientific study of the Yakut Arctic in the period from 1945 to 1991. During this period, science actively developed and contributed to the solution of domestic and foreign policy problems, a powerful research reserve was accumulated, which allows modern Russia to be the undisputed leader in some areas of the development of the Arctic today. However, among the domestic and foreign scientific literature, there are still no special studies that discuss the activities of regional government bodies in organizing scientific research in the Yakut Arctic. Certain aspects of the topic, mainly related to the scientific, industrial and transport development of the Yakut part of the Arctic, are covered in the works summarizing the history of the development of the Russian Arctic.

Keywords: science policy, Yakut ASSR, scientific research, Arctic, Yakutia. Introduction

Research in the Arctic and Northern regions of Yakutia has always been of great scientific and applied importance. Almost immediately after the end of the Great Patriotic War, at the initiative of the republican authorities, scientific research was resumed in Yakutia. So on August 15, 1946, the Council of Ministers of the YASSR adopted Resolution No. 625 of the year to petition the Council of Ministers of the USSR and the Presidium of the USSR Academy of Sciences for the organization of the Yakut Research Base of the USSR Academy of Sciences (YANIB AS USSR), which was already established in 1947. The Yakut research base was supposed to be engaged in a systematic study of the nature and natural resources of the territory of the Yakut ASSR, the history, language and culture of the peoples inhabiting it, as well as to unite and coordinate the conduct of scientific work in the republic.

The Yakut research base was then transformed in 1949 into a branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences. In 1957, the Yakut Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences was included in the newly created Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences in Novosibirsk and became known as the Yakut Branch of the Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences.

An important step in the state policy of scientific research in the Arctic is the adoption on September 17, 1963, by the Bureau of the Yakut Regional Committee of the CPSU of the Resolution on conducting research work on the problems of the development of the Far North. As part of the Yakut northern complex expedition, in pursuance of this decision in 1964-1965, scientific research covered almost the entire Yakut Arctic, YAKSE was the first scientific initiative, within the framework of which an integrated approach was laid to ensure the development of the Arctic regions of the republic.

In the 1980s, a number of fundamental decisions of the government were adopted regarding the problems of the aboriginal ethnic groups of the Arctic, which contributed to the intensification of research activities, the directions and problems of research that were successfully developed by scientists earlier were developed. In particular, the study of the history of the settlement of the Arctic regions of Yakutia by an ancient man, the languages of indigenous peoples, the collection of folklore material, etc., continued. However, at the same time, scientists introduced new approaches

During this period, science actively developed and contributed to the solution of domestic and foreign policy problems, a powerful research reserve was accumulated, when polar research had an unconditional priority, including due to defense considerations, which allows modern Russia today to be the undisputed world leader in some areas. exploration of the Arctic.

The study of state policy in the organization of Arctic science inevitably leads us to the need to comprehend the experience of the republican state and party bodies of the Yakut ASSR in 1945-1991. in this direction.

Thus, the scientific relevance of the study is determined by the need for a comprehensive study of the regional state policy of scientific research in the Yakut sector of the Arctic.

Research methods and principles

The article provides an analysis of the review of the literature of Russian and Yakut authors on the policy of the Soviet state in the field of scientific study of the Yakut Arctic in 1945-1991.

Main results of the discussion

Among the domestic and foreign scientific literature, there are still no special works devoted to the activities of regional government bodies in the organization of scientific research in the Yakut Arctic. Certain aspects of the topic, mainly related to the scientific, industrial and transport development of the Yakut part of the Arctic, are covered in generalizing works on the history of the development of the Russian Arctic.

In the study of state policy in the scientific study of the Arctic, the works of V.N. Bulatov[6]. V.N. Bulatov conducts a detailed analysis of various aspects of the work of the political departments of the Glavsevmorput, cultural and mass work with polar explorers, increasing labor productivity, and popularizing the development of the Arctic in Soviet society. In the work devoted to the Russian North, V.N. Bulatov reveals the important role played by the northern regions in the scientific study of the Arctic[7].

PhD dissertations by D.P. Belyaeva[4], A.A. Saburov[19]. as well as the monograph by Yu.N. Zhukov[13]. In them, the authors explore the relationship between the policy of the Soviet state in the Arctic and scientific research in the region.

I would especially like to note the collective monograph “Russia in the Arctic: State Policy and Development Problems”[16]. The authors examined the imperial, Soviet and post-Soviet periods of the implementation of the state policy of the Russian state in relation to the study and development of the Arctic region of development.

 The works of A.I. Timoshenko[23]. They also consider the Soviet experience of mobilization decisions in the development of the Arctic and the Northern, as well as the problems of continuity in the state regional policy of Russia in relation to the Arctic and the Northern Sea Route[24].

The 50s - 60s of the 20th century in the history of Yakutia were marked by the beginning of a sharp intensification of the transport and industrial development of its Arctic regions. During this period, large-scale activities were launched to search for and develop mineral deposits. The works of Boyakova S.I.[5], Eliseev D.O.[11], Kalemeneva E.A.[15], Sevostyanova A.E.[20], Elert E.Kh. [25], Zubkov K.I. and Karpov V.P. [14], etc.

Important material on the organization of scientific research in the Arctic regions of Yakutia is covered in generalizing works on the history of the Academy of Sciences, the history of the formation and activities of various structural divisions. A.I. Novgorodov, V.N. Antipin and V.N. Eremeev considered the history of creation and the first years of activity of the Yakut branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences[18]. Yu.N. Ermolaeva investigated the problem of organizing academic research in Yakutia in the 20th century, developed a periodization of the activities of the USSR Academy of Sciences in the republic [12]. Serious attention was paid to the organizational component of academic activity in Yakutia by N.A. Kuperstokh [17]. It is also worth noting the collective publication “Academic science in Yakutia (1949–2009)” dedicated to the anniversary of the Yakut branch of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) [1].

Almost immediately after the end of the Great Patriotic War in 1947-1948. The Institute of Permafrost Science of the USSR Academy of Sciences organized the Northern Expedition, headed by N.F. Grigoriev, the work of Suleimanov A.A.[21], biographical study of M.N. Grigoriev [9].

Since the 80s, the increasing attention of Yakut scientists is attracted by the socio-cultural changes that occurred in the Northern and Arctic regions of Yakutia during the Soviet era. So sociologists I.A. Argunov, F.S. Donskoy, N.N. Tikhonov considered socio-demographic changes in the composition of the northern population of the republic. The history of humanitarian research in the Arctic and Northern regions of Yakutia is shown in the articles by L.I. Vinokurova and G.P. Kulakovsky[8], I.S. Astakhova [2].

The study of the history of international scientific cooperation in the Yakutsk part of the Arctic is a new direction in the historiography of Arctic research. It includes articles written by Yakut scientists A.A. Suleimanov, D.A. Shirina [22], S.A. Grigoriev[10], S.M. Baisheva [3] and others.

Conclusion

Despite the large number of works on the history of the development of the Arctic during this period, the role of regional authorities in the implementation of the state policy of scientific study of the Yakut Arctic has rarely become the topic of a special study, as a rule, was considered only as part of more general subjects. In addition, for the most part, they were dealt with not so much by historians as by geographers, economists and representatives of other related disciplines.

Thus, despite the relatively good knowledge of the topic, a number of scientific problems in the history of domestic Arctic research in the second half of the twentieth century remain unresolved. The role of regional government bodies in the organization of scientific research in the Yakut part of the Arctic, including the planning of scientific activities, is poorly reflected. This does not allow us to fully identify the trends in the development of the scientific development of the region and study the process of formation of modern systems for organizing Arctic research.

Конфликт интересов Не указан. Conflict of Interest None declared.
Список литературы / References
  1. Алексеева О.И. Академическая наука в Якутии (1949–2009 гг.) / О.И. Алексеева, С.А. Алексеева, Т.В. Аргунова – Новосибирск: Гео, 2009. – 219 c.
  2. Астахова И.С. Изучение населения Арктических территорий в истории международного и отечественного законодательства: теоретический аспект (80-е гг. ХХ в. – начало ХХI в.) / И.С. Астахова // Гуманитарная наука в трудах молодых исследователей. – Якутск, – 2005. – С. 255-263.
  3. Баишева С.М. Север и Арктика как перспективный регион в сфере международного научного сотрудничества / С.М. Баишева // Внешние связи Якутии сквозь призму времени. – Якутск, – 2019. – С. 95-99.
  4. Беляев Д.П. Государственная политика России в области изучения и освоения архипелагов акватории Баренцева моря во второй половине XIX - первой трети XX веков / Д.П. Беляев: Диссертация на соискание ученой степени кандидата исторических наук. – Мурманск, – 2005. – 210 с.
  5. Боякова С. И. Гуманитарные проблемы Арктики: основные направления научных исследований / С. И. Боякова // Якутия в российском научном пространстве XX – нач. XXI вв.: гуманитарные исследования. – Якутск: Изд- во ЯНЦ СО РАН, – 2005. – С. 56–70.
  6. Булатов В.Н. КПСС - организатор освоения Арктики и Северного морского пути (1917-1980) / В.Н. Булатов. – М., – 1989. – 155 с.
  7. Булатов В.Н. Русский Север. Кн. 5. Ворота в Арктику / В.Н. Булатов. М., – Архангельск, – 2000. – 302 с.
  8. Винокурова Л.И. Хозяйство Севера Якутии в экспедиционных исследованиях с 1920-х до 1960 г. / Л.И. Винокурова, Г.П. Кулаковский // Общество: философия, история, культура. – 2016. – № 6. – С. 62-65.
  9. Григорьев М.Н. Григорьев Николай Филиппович / М.Н. Григорьев. – Якутск: Изд-во ИМЗ СО РАН. 2000. – 63 с.
  10. Григорьев С. А. Взаимодействие государства и институтов гражданского общества в Российской Арктике в конце ХХ в. (на примере общественно-политического движения коренных малочисленных народов Якутии) / С. А. Григорьев // Актуальные проблемы российской государственной политики в Арктике (XX - начало XXI вв.). – Новосибирск: Наука, – 2011. – С. 154-165
  11. Елисеев Д. О. Экономическое освоение Российской Арктики: цели, задачи, подходы / Д. О. Елисеев //Труды Карельского научного центра Российской академии наук. – 2015. – № 3. – С. 4-16.
  12. Ермолаева Ю.Н. Российская академия наук и Якутия. XX век / Ю.Н. Ермолаева // Наука и образование. – 2002. – № 3. – С. 22–27.
  13. Жуков Ю.Н. Сталин: арктический щит / Ю.Н.Жуков. – М., – 2008. – 114 с.
  14. Зубков К. И. Российские проекты в Арктике: преемственность задач и решений / К. И.Зубков, В.П. Карпов // Вестник Тюменского государственного университета. Гуманитарные исследования. Humanitates. – 2019. – Том 5. № 1. – С. 173-187.
  15. Калеменева Е. А. Смена моделей освоения Советского Севера в 1950-е гг. Случай Комиссии по проблемам Севера / Е. А. Калеменева // Сибирские исторические исследования. – 2018. – № 2. – С. 181-200.
  16. Комлева Е.В. Россия в Арктике: государственная политика и проблемы освоения / Е.В.Комлева, Н.А.Куперштох, В.А. Ламин и др. – Новосибирск, Институт истории Сибирского отделения Российской академии наук. – 2017. – 494 с.
  17. Куперштох Н.А. Становление академической науки в Якутии и ее вклад в изучение производительных сил Северо-Востока России / Н.А.Куперштох// Якутский архив. – 2012. – № 1. – С. 9–18.
  18. Новгородов А.И. Академия наук – организатор научных исследований в Якутии / А.И.Новгородов, В.Н.Антипин, В.Н. Еремеев // Академия наук и Сибирь (1917–1957 гг.) / Отв. ред. А.П. Окладников. –Новосибирск, 1977. – С. 266–275.
  19. Сабуров А.А. Организация научных исследований как фактор освоения островов Европейской части Арктики в 1906-1941 гг.: отечественный и норвежский опыт / А.А.Сабуров: Диссертация на соискание ученой степени кандидата исторических наук. – Тюмень, – 2019.
  20. Севостьянова А. Е. Подходы к освоению арктической зоны и развитию восточных регионов России / А. Е. Севостьянова // Регион: экономика и социология. – 2013. – № 3 – С. 59-78.
  21. Сулейманов А.А. Северная экспедиция Якутской научно-исследовательской мерзлотной станции 1947-1948 гг. / А.А. Сулейманов // Манускрипт. – 2020. – Том 13. Выпуск 8. – C. 55-59.
  22. Сулейманов А.А. Роль и возможности России в развитии международного научного сотрудничества в Арктике на примере Республики Саха (Якутия) в конце ХХ века / А.А. Сулейманов, Д.А. Ширина // Актуальные проблемы российской государственной политики в Арктике (XX — начало XXI вв.). – Новосибирск: Наука, – 2011. – С. 138-153.
  23. Тимошенко А.И. Советский опыт освоения Арктики и Северного морского пути: формирование мобилизационной экономики / А.И. Тимошенко //Историко-экономические исследования. – 2013. – Т. 14. № 1-2. – С. 73-95.
  24. Тимошенко А.И. Российская региональная политика в Арктике в ХХ−ХХI вв.: проблемы стратегической преемственности / А.И. Тимошенко // Арктика и Север. – 2011 – №4. – С. 1-13.
  25. Элерт Э. Х. Россия в Арктике: проблемы изучения исторического опыта освоения региона / Э. Х. Элерт // Гуманитарные науки в Сибири. – 2016. – № 3. – С. 5-12.

Список литературы на английском языке / References in English

  1. Alekseeva O.I. Akademicheskaya nauka v Yakutii (1949–2009 gg.) [Academic science in Yakutia (1949-2009)] / I. Alekseeva, S.A. Alekseeva, T.V. Argunova – Novosibirsk: Geo, 2009. – 219 p. [in Russian]
  2. Astahova I.S. Izuchenie naseleniya Arkticheskih territorij v istorii mezhdunarodnogo i otechestvennogo zakonodatel'stva: teoreticheskij aspekt (80-e gg. ХХ – nachalo ХХI v.) [Studying the population of the Arctic territories in the history of international and domestic legislation: theoretical aspect (80s of the XX century - the beginning of the XXI century)] / I.S Astakhova // Gumanitarnaya nauka v trudah molodyh issledovatelej. [Humanities in the works of young researchers]. – Yakutsk, – 2005. – P. 255-263. [in Russian]
  3. Baisheva S.M. Sever i Arktika kak perspektivnyj region v sfere mezhdunarodnogo nauchnogo sotrudnichestva [The North and the Arctic as a promising region in the field of international scientific cooperation] /S.M. Baisheva // Vneshnie svyazi Yakutii skvoz' prizmu vremeni. [External relations of Yakutia through the prism of time]. – Yakutsk, – 2019. – 95-99. [in Russian]
  4. Belyaev D.P. Gosudarstvennaya politika Rossii v oblasti izucheniya i osvoeniya arhipelagov akvatorii Barenceva morya vo vtoroj polovine XIX - pervoj treti XX vekov: Dissertaciya na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kandidata istoricheskih nauk. [State policy of Russia in the field of the study and development of the archipelagos of the Barents Sea in the second half of the XIX - first third of the XX centuries: Dissertation for the degree of candidate of historical sciences]. /D.P. Belyaev. – Murmansk, – 2005. – 210 p. [in Russian]
  5. Boyakova S. I. Gumanitarnye problemy Arktiki: osnovnye napravleniya nauchnyh issledovanij [Humanitarian problems of the Arctic: the main directions of scientific research] / S. I. Boyakova // Yakutiya v rossijskom nauchnom prostranstve XX – nach. XXI vv.: gumanitarnye issledovaniya. [Yakutia in the Russian scientific space XX - early. XXI centuries: humanitarian research]. – Yakutsk, – 2005. – pp. 56–70. [in Russian]
  6. Bulatov V.N. KPSS - organizator osvoeniya Arktiki i Severnogo morskogo puti (1917-1980). [The CPSU was the organizer of the development of the Arctic and the Northern Sea Route (1917-1980)] / V.N. Bulatov. – M., – 1989. – 155 p. [in Russian]
  7. Bulatov V.N. Russkij Sever. Kn. 5. Vorota v Arktiku. [Russian North. Book. 5. Gateway to the Arctic] / V.N. Bulatov. M. – Arkhangelsk, – 2000. – 302 p. [in Russian]
  8. Vinokurova L.I. Hozyajstvo Severa Yakutii v ekspedicionnyh issledovaniyah s 1920-h do 1960 g. [The economy of the North of Yakutia in expeditionary research from the 1920s to 1960] / L.I. Vinokurova,G.P. Kulakovsky // Obshchestvo: filosofiya, istoriya, kul'tura. [Society: philosophy, history, culture]. – 2016. – No. 6. – p. 62-65. [in Russian]
  9. Grigor'ev M. N. Grigor'ev Nikolaj Filippovich. [Grigoriev Nikolay Filippovich] / M. N. Grigoriev. – Yakutsk, – 2000. – 63 p. [in Russian]
  10. Grigor'ev S. A. Vzaimodejstvie gosudarstva i institutov grazhdanskogo obshchestva v Rossijskoj Arktike v konce ХХ (na primere obshchestvenno-politicheskogo dvizheniya korennyh malochislennyh narodov Yakutii) [Interaction between the state and civil society institutions in the Russian Arctic at the end of the twentieth century. (on the example of the social and political movement of the indigenous peoples of Yakutia)] / S.A. Grigoriev // Aktual'nye problemy rossijskoj gosudarstvennoj politiki v Arktike (XX - nachalo XXI vv.). [Actual problems of Russian state policy in the Arctic (XX - early XXI centuries)]. – Novosibirsk, – 2011. – p. 154-165 [in Russian]
  11. Eliseev D.O. Ekonomicheskoe osvoenie Rossijskoj Arktiki: celi, zadachi, podhody [Economic development of the Russian Arctic: goals, objectives, approaches] / D.O. Eliseev // Trudy Karel'skogo nauchnogo centra Rossijskoj akademii nauk. [Proceedings of the Karelian Scientific Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. – 2015. – No. 3. – p. 4-16. [in Russian]
  12. Ermolaeva YU.N. Rossijskaya akademiya nauk i Yakutiya. XX vek [Russian Academy of Sciences and Yakutia. XX century] / Yu.N. Ermolaeva // Nauka i obrazovanie [ Science and education]. – 2002. – No. 3. – P. 22–27. [in Russian]
  13. Zhukov YU.N. Stalin: arkticheskij shchit. [Stalin: arctic shield] / Yu.N. Zhukov. – M., – 2008. – 114 p. [in Russian]
  14. Zubkov K. I. Rossijskie proekty v Arktike: preemstvennost' zadach i reshenij [Russian projects in the Arctic: continuity of tasks and solutions] / K.I.Zubkov, V.P. Karpov // Vestnik Tyumenskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Gumanitarnye issledovaniya. Humanitates. [Bulletin of the Tyumen State University. Humanities research. Humanitates] – 2019. – Vol. 5.No. 1. – P. 173-187. [in Russian]
  15. Kalemeneva E. A. Smena modelej osvoeniya Sovetskogo Severa v 1950-e gg. Sluchaj Komissii po problemam Severa [Change of models for the development of the Soviet North in the 1950s. The case of the Commission on the Problems of the North] / E. A. Kalemeneva // Sibirskie istoricheskie issledovaniya. [Siberian Historical Research]. – 2018. – No. 2. – 181-200. [in Russian]
  16. Komleva E.V. Rossiya v Arktike: gosudarstvennaya politika i problemy osvoeniya. [Russia in the Arctic: State Policy and Development Problems] / E.V.Komleva, N.A. Kupershtokh, V.A. Lamin et al. – Novosibirsk, – 2017. – 494 p. [in Russian]
  17. Kupershtoh N.A. Stanovlenie akademicheskoj nauki v Yakutii i ee vklad v izuchenie proizvoditel'nyh sil Severo-Vostoka Rossii [Formation of academic science in Yakutia and its contribution to the study of the productive forces of the North-East of Russia / N.A. Kupershtokh // Yakutskij arhiv. [Yakutsk archive] - – 2012. – No. 1. – P. 9–18. [in Russian]
  18. Novgorodov A.I. Akademiya nauk – organizator nauchnyh issledovanij v Yakutii [Academy of Sciences - organizer of scientific research in Yakutia] / A.I.Novgorodov, V.N.Antipin, V.N. Eremeev // Akademiya nauk i Sibir' (1917–1957 gg.) [Academy of Sciences and Siberia (1917-1957)] – Novosibirsk, – 1977. – p. 266–275 [in Russian]
  19. Saburov A.A. Organizaciya nauchnyh issledovanij kak faktor osvoeniya ostrovov Evropejskoj chasti Arktiki v 1906-1941 gg.: otechestvennyj i norvezhskij opyt [Organization of scientific research as a factor in the development of the islands of the European part of the Arctic in 1906-1941: domestic and Norwegian experience] / A.A. Saburov. Dissertation for the degree of candidate of historical sciences. – Tyumen, – 2019. [in Russian]
  20. Sevost'yanova A. E. Podhody k osvoeniyu arkticheskoj zony i razvitiyu vostochnyh regionov Rossii [Approaches to the development of the Arctic zone and the development of the eastern regions of Russia] / A.E. Sevostyanova // Region: ekonomika i sociologiya [Region: economics and sociology] – 2013. – No. 3 – p. 59-78. [in Russian]
  21. Sulejmanov A.A. Severnaya ekspediciya Yakutskoj nauchno-issledovatel'skoj merzlotnoj stancii 1947-1948 gg. [Northern Expedition of the Yakutsk Research Permafrost Station 1947-1948] / A.A. Suleimanov // Manuskript [Manuscript]. – 2020. – Volume 13. Issue 8. – P. 55-59. [in Russian]
  22. Sulejmanov A.A., Shirina D.A. Rol' i vozmozhnosti Rossii v razvitii mezhdunarodnogo nauchnogo sotrudnichestva v Arktike na primere Respubliki Saha (Yakutiya) v konce ХХ veka [The role and capabilities of Russia in the development of international scientific cooperation in the Arctic on the example of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) at the end of the XX century] / A.A.Suleimanov, D.A. Shirin // Aktual'nye problemy rossijskoj gosudarstvennoj politiki v Arktike (XX — nachalo XXI vv.). [Actual problems of Russian state policy in the Arctic (XX - early XXI centuries)]. – Novosibirsk,– 2011. – 138-153. [in Russian]
  23. Timoshenko A. I. Sovetskij opyt osvoeniya Arktiki i Severnogo morskogo puti: formirovanie mobilizacionnoj ekonomiki [Soviet experience in the development of the Arctic and the Northern Sea Route: the formation of a mobilization economy] / A.I. Timoshenko // Istoriko-ekonomicheskie issledovaniya. [Historical and economic research]. – 2013. – Vol. 14. No. 1-2. – p. 73-95. [in Russian]
  24. Timoshenko A.I. Rossijskaya regional'naya politika v Arktike v ХХ−ХХI vv.: problemy strategicheskoj preemstvennosti [Russian regional policy in the Arctic in the XX-XXI centuries: problems of strategic continuity] / I. Timoshenko // Arktika i Sever [Arctic and North]. – 2011 – No. 4. – p. 1-13. [in Russian]
  25. Elert E. H. Rossiya v Arktike: problemy izucheniya istoricheskogo opyta osvoeniya regiona [Russia in the Arctic: problems of studying the historical experience of the development of the region] / E. Kh. Elert // Gumanitarnye nauki v Sibiri [Humanities in Siberia] – 2016. – No. 3. – p. 5-12. [in Russian]